The Scared, the Profane, and the Similarity

The bombardment scene in The Forbidden Zone enraged me. Like actually¬†enraged. I wanted to post about it prior to class but felt I needed to collect my thoughts and rein in my disgust before ranting all over our blog. Thanks to Morgan’s confidence-inducing and accepting-of-my-crazy pep talk, I’m throwing caution to the wind (or rather, blowing it out the this ticking time bomb I call a brain).

Mary Borden disgusted me. The narrator watched the bombardment happen and did nothing. Of course, they detailed the scene (a sick thing to do if you ask me), but they didn’t warn anyone though they saw the planes. They didn’t help of the people though they saw them running. They didn’t do anything but watch. I refuse to believe that a stunned demeanor makes up for these actions.

Transitioning to an aerial view of the destruction disgusted me even further. Never in my life have I had such a visceral and actual real physical reaction to a text. I’m talking my hands got sweaty, my face got hot, and I threw the book across the room. Okay, okay, I didn’t actually–books are sacred things, mind you–but I wanted to. I really¬†really wanted to. The telling of the story from above gave the narrator God-like power over the destruction. And if not merely over the destruction, it gave the narrator the power to avoid it. It equated the dichotomy of power and destruction with that of the sacred and the profane.

Giving the narrator that power almost seemed like a religious stab. As though anyone believing in a God or willing to exonerate their God from allowing such a thing to happen had transitioned themselves from the sacred to the profane. Borden almost flips the meaning on the two words.

Power = proof of sacredness and sacred = profane

In class we discussed how there might not be any real evidence of religious suggestions so far in the book. I disagree. I think Borden is making clear and direct accusations regarding religion.

209 thoughts on “The Scared, the Profane, and the Similarity

  1. This is the angry post I was waiting for, Jordan! I feel like this is basically like what we talked about in our group today and I get what you are saying. You are so able to have these feelings regardless of what others think. I am super glad that I was able to help you feel comfortable taking to the blog about this! I see it from both sides, what you are saying and also the inevitability of this event. After what we talked about in class, how Borden is taking on the perspective of the enemy and the real Borden is down on the ground trying to help people, I don’t hate it AS much as I did. But also, this is the reality of the war. Is it gross that it is now in a book for forever and there is nothing that can be done about it, yes. Is it sad that no one did anything to try to warn people or save them, yes. But it goes with the reality of what was happening during this time. I don’t think there was much that could be done to save these people, a warning might not of changed things, but then again I might have.

  2. Wow, this reading is extremely interesting to me. I didn’t read it this way at all!

    I think just because we were positioned with the planes, with the overhead view it doesn’t mean we’re supposed to assume that the narrator is standing doing nothing in this scene. To me it seemed more like she was including herself as the ants, and this view we had was from another party, an imagined viewpoint. Projecting Borden as the author or a narrator we expect to act heroically in this moment seems unfair to what we’ve been given so far in this book, to the unique and striking ways Borden plays with POV and language. I mean, we don’t even really have a clear narrator in this text. The point of view changes, even the style of the stories change, some read more like children’s stories, some read like a tour, some like a firsthand account. I mean, at some points we have ourselves positioned with inanimate things even though we’ve been told this is a factual account, whether it’s the house that speaks, or the landscape itself!

    I read the indifference of the language you were disgusted by, the description of people as ants has to do with the technology of war itself, and how war makes the individual feel small, unimportant, insectoid, inhuman. I think it is an extremely powerful, evocative, and effective scene in the text.

    Your comment on it relating to a critique on religion or a God is definitely something I want to think more about (and I think Dr. Scanlon said there’s more about it later in the text perhaps?). It makes me think about other modernist texts (this text screams modernist to me!) which also comment on the existence of a God in face of the terror of WWI.

    What do other people think about this??? You got me thinking!

  3. Pingback: generic ventolin

  4. Pingback: viagra sales

  5. Pingback: viagra substitute

  6. Pingback: chloroquine cost uk

  7. Pingback: careprost eyelash enhancer

  8. Pingback: overnight delivery viagra

  9. Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online

  10. Pingback: ed drugs online from india

  11. Pingback: cialistodo.com

  12. Pingback: catapres 100 mcg over the counter

  13. Pingback: ceclor 250mg for sale

  14. Pingback: ceftin 250mg purchase

  15. Pingback: cheap celebrex 100 mg

  16. Pingback: celexa medication

  17. Pingback: cephalexin cheap

  18. Pingback: cipro uk

  19. Pingback: where can i buy claritin 10 mg

  20. Pingback: online casino games for real money

  21. Pingback: online casino with free signup bonus real money usa

  22. Pingback: free slots

  23. Pingback: online gambling

  24. Pingback: ocean casino online nj

  25. Pingback: best online casino

  26. Pingback: slots real money

  27. Pingback: best online casino real money

  28. Pingback: car insurance price

  29. Pingback: auto-owners insurance

  30. Pingback: cheap liability car insurance quotes

  31. Pingback: amica car insurance quotes

  32. Pingback: auto home insurance

  33. Pingback: geico car insurance

  34. Pingback: general insurance quote

  35. Pingback: direct general car insurance quotes

  36. Pingback: plymouth rock car insurance quotes

  37. Pingback: fast personal loans

  38. Pingback: advance payday loans

  39. Pingback: installment loans with bad credit

  40. Pingback: personal loan online

  41. Pingback: safe viagra online

  42. Pingback: is cbd oil legal in ny

  43. Pingback: cbd oil for pain at walmart

  44. Pingback: generic sildenafil coupon

  45. Pingback: cannabis seeds high in cbd

  46. Pingback: cbd oil side effects in cats

  47. Pingback: sildenafil 100 mg best price

  48. Pingback: cbd oil benefits webmd

  49. Pingback: lowest price for generic viagra

  50. Pingback: over the counter viagra 2018

  51. Pingback: cbd oil near me for sale

  52. Pingback: academic essay writer

  53. Pingback: buy essay papers online

  54. Pingback: assignment helps

  55. Pingback: viagra 200mg tablet

  56. Pingback: buy college essay

  57. Pingback: essay write

  58. Pingback: how to buy generic viagra from canada

  59. Pingback: best custom essay writing service

  60. Pingback: how to assign oxidation number

  61. Pingback: viagra 500mg price

  62. Pingback: clozaril 50mg purchase

  63. Pingback: colchicine 0,5mg canada

  64. Pingback: combivent united states

  65. Pingback: coreg without prescription

  66. Pingback: compazine 5mg medication

  67. Pingback: coumadin nz

  68. Pingback: cozaar 100mg generic

  69. Pingback: cheap crestor

  70. Pingback: dapsone caps without a prescription

  71. Pingback: cheapest depakote 500mg

  72. Pingback: diamox 250 mg without prescription

  73. Pingback: erythromycin 250 mg united states

  74. Pingback: how to purchase etodolac 400mg

  75. Pingback: flomax 0,2mg purchase

  76. Pingback: flonase nasal spray without a prescription

  77. Pingback: garcinia cambogia 100caps generic

  78. Pingback: buy imdur 20 mg

  79. Pingback: cost of imodium

  80. Pingback: go to these guys

  81. Pingback: imuran 50 mg usa

  82. Pingback: indocin 50 mg prices

  83. Pingback: order lamisil

  84. Pingback: lopid usa

  85. Pingback: lopressor 25 mg tablets

  86. Pingback: luvox tablets

  87. Pingback: how to purchase meclizine 25mg

  88. Pingback: buy mestinon

  89. Pingback: cheapest micardis

  90. Pingback: motrin nz

  91. Pingback: prednisolone pharmacy

  92. Pingback: proair inhaler 100 mcg without prescription

  93. Pingback: procardia 30mg nz

  94. Pingback: how to buy proscar 5mg

  95. Pingback: protonix coupon

  96. Pingback: provigil united kingdom

  97. Pingback: pulmicort generic

  98. Pingback: pyridium tablets

  99. Pingback: remeron 15 mg usa

  100. Pingback: where to buy retin-a cream 0.025%

  101. Pingback: robaxin 500mg otc

  102. Pingback: rogaine prices

  103. Pingback: where to buy seroquel 100mg

  104. Pingback: levitra vs viagra

  105. Pingback: spiriva 9 mcg online pharmacy

  106. Pingback: tenormin pharmacy

  107. Pingback: intext:cialis inurl:cart.php?id=

  108. Pingback: toprol 50mg otc

  109. Pingback: payton hall fifi fox viagra

  110. Pingback: order tricor 160mg

  111. Pingback: valtrex generic

  112. Pingback: wheb will viagra go generic

  113. Pingback: verapamil 40mg purchase

  114. Pingback: voltaren 100 mg uk

  115. Pingback: wellbutrin generic

  116. Pingback: cialis implant

  117. Pingback: zovirax tablets

  118. Pingback: zyprexa cheap

  119. Pingback: zyvox no prescription

  120. Pingback: tadalafil nz

  121. Pingback: where to buy escitalopram

  122. Pingback: viagra jarow jonathan m d

  123. Pingback: pioglitazone price

  124. Pingback: what is the ingredients in cialis

  125. Pingback: spironolactone without a doctor prescription

  126. Pingback: will viagra stop working

  127. Pingback: glimepiride without a doctor prescription

  128. Pingback: how to buy leflunomide 20mg

  129. Pingback: donepezil without prescription

  130. Pingback: anastrozole cheap

  131. Pingback: irbesartan pills

  132. Pingback: dutasteride otc

  133. Pingback: olmesartan 20mg tablets

  134. Pingback: buspirone 10 mg generic

  135. Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg united kingdom

  136. Pingback: where can i buy citalopram 20mg

  137. Pingback: order cephalexin

  138. Pingback: ciprofloxacin 250 mg pharmacy

  139. Pingback: clindamycin 300 mg tablet

  140. Pingback: clozapine 25 mg australia

  141. Pingback: rosuvastatin 10mg without a doctor prescription

  142. Pingback: where can i buy trazodone 100mg

  143. Pingback: tolterodine coupon

  144. Pingback: cost of acetazolamide 250mg

  145. Pingback: fluconazole usa

  146. Pingback: amoxicillin dose for cats

  147. Pingback: phenytoin generic

  148. Pingback: oxybutyninmg online

  149. Pingback: azithromycin 250 mg side effects

  150. Pingback: doxycycline 100mg online pharmacy

  151. Pingback: celebrex for muscle pain

  152. Pingback: cephalexin 500 ml para que es

  153. Pingback: buy bisacodyl 5 mg

  154. Pingback: venlafaxinemg pharmacy

  155. Pingback: cymbalta ear ringing

  156. Pingback: amitriptyline canada

  157. Pingback: amoxicillin allergic rash

  158. Pingback: permethrin usa

  159. Pingback: erythromycin australia

  160. Pingback: uhgkppqb

  161. Pingback: estradiol cost

  162. Pingback: how much azithromycin for chlamydia

  163. Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg

  164. Pingback: alendronate united kingdom

  165. Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100 mg without a doctor prescription

  166. Pingback: cymbalta vs effexor panic

  167. Pingback: how to buy glipizide 5 mg

  168. Pingback: isosorbide over the counter

  169. Pingback: sumatriptan pharmacy

  170. Pingback: sildenafil phenetic

  171. Pingback: cost of azathioprine 50mg

  172. Pingback: propranolol coupon

  173. Pingback: dixiestrailerpark viagra

  174. Pingback: how to purchase lamotrigine 25 mg

  175. Pingback: terbinafine australia

  176. Pingback: where to buy digoxin 0.25 mg

  177. Pingback: levothyroxine mcg price

  178. Pingback: cheap gemfibrozil 300mg

  179. Pingback: clotrimazole medication

  180. Pingback: cost of metoclopramide

  181. Pingback: female viagra pills

  182. Pingback: sildenafil citrate revatio

  183. Pingback: cheapest cialis uk

  184. Pingback: viagra generic

  185. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg

  186. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg

  187. Pingback: generic for viagra

  188. Pingback: cialis tadalafil 20 mg tablets

  189. Pingback: how do you get cialis

  190. Pingback: cialis 2 mg

  191. Pingback: cialis online

  192. Pingback: order generic cialis online

  193. Pingback: viagra soft tabs cheap

  194. Pingback: where to buy sildenafil

  195. Pingback: buy sildenafil online

  196. Pingback: tadalafil for women

  197. Pingback: viagra over the counter us

  198. Pingback: how to take cialis 20mg

  199. Pingback: viagra prescription online

  200. Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription

  201. Pingback: overnight cialis

  202. Pingback: generic viagra

  203. Pingback: sildenafil mexico cheapest

  204. Pingback: viagra pharmacy cost

  205. Pingback: cialis on the web

  206. Pingback: best place buy viagra online

  207. Pingback: canadian herbal viagra

  208. Pingback: read reviews on online med sotes for viagra without prescription

  209. Pingback: levitra vs cialis

Leave a Reply