Sean’s Bridge to the Blog

In class today we focused on Owen, specifically his use of the religious in “The Parable of the Old Man and the Young” and some of the formal elements in “Dulce et Decorum Est.” One thing that I wish we touched more on was Owen’s portrayal not only of war, but nationalism/the nation as an idea or concept.

I bring up this topic because in the famous final lines of “Dulce et Decorum Est,” Owen does not make a statement about dying for your country in WWI specifically. Rather, his statement is more general, saying (translated) “It is sweet and honorable to die for one’s country.” If he wanted to, he could have expressed his frustration about WWI itself and the reasons why he saw this particular war as egregious (as he did in the “The Parable of the Old Man and the Young”). However, by choosing not to do so, we can assume that Owen thinks it is never “sweet and honorable to die for one’s country,” no matter the circumstance. This, of course, goes against the prevailing narrative that dying in service of one’s country is the most honorable thing one can do (e.g. “The Charge of the Light Brigade”). If we assume that this is what Owen intended (and not that he used the lines just so that he could directly invoke Horace), the most obvious question is – why? If it was not because WWI was uniquely horrific, why does Owen have such a distaste for ever dying for one’s country? Or, as is certainly possible, am I reading too much into this? Is Owen’s reasoning tied only to the nature of WWI itself? Does he spend the majority of the poem describing, in nauseatingly vivid detail, the experience of a WWI soldier in the trenches because his opinion is only meant to be read as a response to WWI? Or, does he do so because he believes it to be the most way to get his message across?

I think a potential answer to these questions can be found in an Owen poem that we did not talk about in class today, “Smile, Smile, Smile.” To commit the heresy of paraphrase, the poem is about a group of soldiers reading an issue of an English newspaper and lamenting about all of the propaganda that it is spreading. One such piece of propaganda comes at the end of the quoted article, saying “‘The greatest glory will be theirs who fought, / Who kept this nation in integrity.'” (16-17). Immediately following this we read,

“Nation? – The half-limbed readers did not chafe / But smiled at one another curiously / Like secret men who know their secret safe. / (This is the thing they know and never speak, / That England one by one had fled to France, Not many elsewhere now, save under France.)” (18-23).

Here, it seems to me that Owen is suggesting that they (the soldiers) are England itself and that those at home have no right to speak of the “nation” of England because they are no longer a part of it. In some ways this seems compatible with sentiments such as Rupert Brooke’s “If I should die, think only this of me: That there is some corner of a foreign field / that is for ever England” (From “The Soldier,” 1-3). Yet, Owen’s sentiment is also vastly different. For Owen, the soldiers are not an extension of England, or fighting for England, they are England. Or, perhaps, there is no longer any England at all. Maybe England can only exist under the confines of France, because that is where the war is. To be honest, I’m not sure. The more I think about these lines the more interpretations I come up with. All of this is to say that Owen’s idea of the nation, especially when it is at war, is far from the convention at the time. And I think this view of the nation (whatever it is) can be used in order to read the ending of “Dulce et Decorum Est.” Perhaps Owen is so against dying for one’s country because his view of what a nation actually is has tainted his view of patriotism/nationalism. Does any of this make sense? What other readings can you come up with for these poems and their relation (or lack thereof) to each other? Did I miss Owen talking about nation in a different poem? Are there any other Owen poems that can be used in order to explain his supposed general distaste for dying for one’s country? Have his experiences in WWI changed his opinion on what it means to be a nation? Have I been thinking too much about the artificiality of the nation because of my postcolonial literature class? Hopefully some answers come as we stumble across this semester’s bleak ending.

Word Count: 800

165 thoughts on “Sean’s Bridge to the Blog

  1. Pingback: cialis 20mg

  2. Pingback: ciprofloxacin over the counter usa

  3. Pingback: albuterol inhaler for sale generic

  4. Pingback: cheapest viagra

  5. Pingback: naltrexone drug

  6. Pingback: chloroquine brand name in india

  7. Pingback: cialis for sale

  8. Pingback: lumigan price

  9. Pingback: alternative for viagra

  10. Pingback: buy viagra professional

  11. Pingback: buy chloroquine phosphate

  12. Pingback: viagra online canada

  13. Pingback: buy cialis

  14. Pingback: amaryl 2mg without a doctor prescription

  15. Pingback: cardizem 30mg for sale

  16. Pingback: cost of catapres

  17. Pingback: ceftin uk

  18. Pingback: cost of celexa

  19. Pingback: how to buy cephalexin

  20. Pingback: claritin tablet

  21. Pingback: empire casino online

  22. Pingback: casino slots

  23. Pingback: online casino usa real money

  24. Pingback: real money online casino

  25. Pingback: online casinos

  26. Pingback: real casino

  27. Pingback: slots online

  28. Pingback: online slots real money

  29. Pingback: real casino games

  30. Pingback: doubleu casino online casino

  31. Pingback: cheap car insurance

  32. Pingback: car insurance quotes renewal

  33. Pingback: american car insurance quotes

  34. Pingback: united car insurance

  35. Pingback: car insurance quotes companies

  36. Pingback: erie car insurance quotes

  37. Pingback: geico car insurance quotes

  38. Pingback: personal loans now

  39. Pingback: instant payday loans

  40. Pingback: payday loans birmingham al

  41. Pingback: quick loans for poor credit

  42. Pingback: online payday

  43. Pingback: guaranteed personal loans

  44. Pingback: best cbd oil on amazon

  45. Pingback: cbd oil side effects

  46. Pingback: cbd oil

  47. Pingback: cbd in marijuana

  48. Pingback: medterra cbd oil website

  49. Pingback: best cbd oil for pain for sale

  50. Pingback: best uk essay writing service

  51. Pingback: american essay writing service

  52. Pingback: assignment define

  53. Pingback: pay for essay online

  54. Pingback: legitimate essay writing service

  55. Pingback: online homework planner

  56. Pingback: custom essay writing

  57. Pingback: clomid coupon

  58. Pingback: cheapest colchicine

  59. Pingback: where to buy combivent

  60. Pingback: coumadin cost

  61. Pingback: cozaar over the counter

  62. Pingback: crestor online pharmacy

  63. Pingback: cymbalta 60mg uk

  64. Pingback: how to purchase dapsone 1000caps

  65. Pingback: ddavp australia

  66. Pingback: depakote no prescription

  67. Pingback: how to purchase differin

  68. Pingback: elavil 50 mg usa

  69. Pingback: erythromycin price

  70. Pingback: etodolac pills

  71. Pingback: where can i buy garcinia cambogia caps

  72. Pingback: how to purchase geodon

  73. Pingback: hyzaar 12,5 mg otc

  74. Pingback: imdur 40 mg medication

  75. Pingback: where to buy imitrex

  76. Pingback: click for more

  77. Pingback: imuran 25 mg for sale

  78. Pingback: indocin united states

  79. Pingback: levaquin for sale

  80. Pingback: lopid purchase

  81. Pingback: luvox 100mg medication

  82. Pingback: periactin prices

  83. Pingback: plaquenil 400mg medication

  84. Pingback: prednisolone nz

  85. Pingback: prevacid 15mg otc

  86. Pingback: prilosec 10 mg online

  87. Pingback: order proscar

  88. Pingback: protonix 20 mg tablet

  89. Pingback: order provigil

  90. Pingback: pulmicort 200 mcg cheap

  91. Pingback: reglan 10mg without prescription

  92. Pingback: remeron united kingdom

  93. Pingback: how to purchase risperdal 2 mg

  94. Pingback: how to purchase rogaine

  95. Pingback: where can i buy seroquel 100mg

  96. Pingback: cost of skelaxin

  97. Pingback: where can i buy spiriva 9 mcg

  98. Pingback: cost of tenormin

  99. Pingback: toprol pharmacy

  100. Pingback: tricor nz

  101. Pingback: order valtrex

  102. Pingback: verapamil 40mg nz

  103. Pingback: voltaren no prescription

  104. Pingback: wellbutrin 150mg medication

  105. Pingback: zestril 2,5mg coupon

  106. Pingback: More hints

  107. Pingback: zocor 20mg cheap

  108. Pingback: zyloprim cost

  109. Pingback: zyprexa united states

  110. Pingback: buy zyvox

  111. Pingback: sildenafil united kingdom

  112. Pingback: escitalopram 10mg coupon

  113. Pingback: aripiprazole pharmacy

  114. Pingback: pioglitazone united kingdom

  115. Pingback: how to purchase fexofenadine

  116. Pingback: glimepiride coupon

  117. Pingback: leflunomide 20 mg nz

  118. Pingback: atomoxetine 10mg prices

  119. Pingback: donepezil 5 mg pharmacy

  120. Pingback: anastrozole usa

  121. Pingback: irbesartan nz

  122. Pingback: dutasteride 0,5mg united kingdom

  123. Pingback: cheapest buspirone 10mg

  124. Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg no prescription

  125. Pingback: cefuroxime 250mg uk

  126. Pingback: celecoxib 100 mg without prescription

  127. Pingback: citalopram for sale

  128. Pingback: order loratadine 10mg

  129. Pingback: clindamycin canada

  130. Pingback: clozapine 100mg online

  131. Pingback: prochlorperazine 5 mg without prescription

  132. Pingback: carvedilol 6.25 mg online pharmacy

  133. Pingback: warfarin price

  134. Pingback: cheap rosuvastatin 10mg

  135. Pingback: order divalproex 250 mg

  136. Pingback: acetazolamide over the counter

  137. Pingback: where can i buy fluconazole 100 mg

  138. Pingback: phenytoin without a prescription

  139. Pingback: oxybutynin over the counter

  140. Pingback: where can i buy doxycycline 100mg

  141. Pingback: bisacodyl prices

  142. Pingback: order venlafaxine 37.5mg

  143. Pingback: how to buy amitriptyline 50 mg

  144. Pingback: permethrin 30g generic

  145. Pingback: erythromycin 500 mg australia

  146. Pingback: cheap estradiol

  147. Pingback: tamsulosinmg australia

  148. Pingback: alendronate 70 mg tablet

  149. Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100 mg uk

  150. Pingback: glipizide 5mg for sale

  151. Pingback: hydrochlorothiazide tablets

  152. Pingback: isosorbide tablets

  153. Pingback: sumatriptan 100 mg for sale

  154. Pingback: how to buy loperamide

  155. Pingback: where can i buy azathioprine

  156. Pingback: propranolol united kingdom

  157. Pingback: lamotrigine 200 mg purchase

  158. Pingback: where to buy terbinafine

  159. Pingback: how to purchase digoxin 0.25mg

  160. Pingback: atorvastatin 40mg for sale

  161. Pingback: gemfibrozil 300 mg cheap

  162. Pingback: where can i buy metoprolol 50mg

  163. Pingback: clotrimazole 10g without prescription

  164. Pingback: metoclopramide 10mg canada

  165. Pingback: american college rheumatology hydroxychloroquine

Leave a Reply