Morgan’s Bridge to the Blog

Hey guys! So today in class we spent a lot of time talking about the relationship between Catherine (Cat) and Frederic Henry’s relationship in the novel. We talked about the layers of their relationship, how they pretend that the hospital room and the hotel room is their own little house and even contemplated if their relationship was real or fake. Obviously, both Cat and Henry have some personal things going on and maybe that is why they are together, they could be a comfort for each other in some weird way. Being someone who has always been in love with the idea of being in love, I got really caught up in the romantic relationships we have seen so far this semester.

But how does the portrayal of love in “All Quiet,” “Not So Quiet,” and “A Farewell to Arms” do? How are they similar or different? Have we seen the type of relationship that Henry and Cat have before?

I think this all goes back to the glorification of wartime and the idea that everything works out in the end. It is the true romantic story: man goes off to war, gets injured, a pretty nurse takes care of him, nurses him back to health, they fall in love and get married, have a family and live happily ever after. Super sappy and in the end everything is wrapped up nicely with a pretty little bow and they live in a house with a white picket fence. It is like this was the dream of the time, the type of relationship people adored and wished themselves to be in. Pictures from this time and posters like that of which Dr. Scanlon showed us in class today add to this belief of the romanticized war.

However, we have already seen how Henry and Cat’s relationship deviates from this idea since she gets pregnant out of wedlock. Their mental states, their perspectives, and their actual relationship is everything outside of what the desired relationship was. So, could their relationship be here to mock this idea of romance during the wartime or is it an accurate depiction of two broken people finding relief and comfort within one another which makes life a little more bearable? And if so, what is trying to be shown here? Now, thinking back to our other books, how about the relationship Nellie finds herself in at the end of “Not So Quiet”? We discussed how she said she would never marry someone who was in the war and was injured because it would be a constant reminder of the things she witnessed, however, she gets engaged to Roy and accepts him even after his injury. Does this make their relationship the same as Henry and Cat’s? If so how? Do you think that these relationships that we see in these wartime stories are parodying the expectations that everyone believed would happen at the time, making fun of the dreams young women had of falling in love with brave soldiers, or do you think that they are just showing the actual “romance” that would come about during a time like this?

Word Count: 523

 

180 thoughts on “Morgan’s Bridge to the Blog

  1. You asked some very thought provoking questions. I look at the romanticized versions of war posters and read these books thinking that the people who lived during WWI had very different experiences and perspectives. Americans were disconnected by an ocean, the only ones who endured this war were volunteers who traveled overseas and military. Europeans had fragmented perspectives based on where they lived next to the battlefields in their former farms fields, battle sounds being heard across the North Sea, and people who never saw anything but broken soldiers and death telegrams. I think the disparity of experiences leaves people open to romanticizing the war. Frederic and Catherine’s romance could be both an escape from the reality of war and a parody of romance in wartime. Nellie and Roy feels more realistic. She denied wanting to to marry a soldier/veteran, but their shared experiences would have fulfilled her more after the war than a man who had never served.

    • I really like how you looked at the experiences and views on the war based on location! I had sort of always known that this was an influence, but never really fully thought about this. I know locations causes varying attitudes about supporting the war and what it was all for, and it totally makes sense that location would also totally change to relationships caused/developed during this periods as well. I just really think that this type of love is some sort of motivation to get men to serve and for women to volunteer. I mean, maybe you’ll find your true love, maybe you’ll lose your life, but you 100% will be mentally destroyed.

  2. Pingback: albuterol inhaler

  3. Pingback: viagra pill for man

  4. Pingback: buy tylenol

  5. Pingback: tadalafil without a doctor's prescription

  6. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine price

  7. Pingback: cost of viagra with insurance

  8. Pingback: buy viagra 100mg

  9. Pingback: buy chloroquine phosphate

  10. Pingback: Cialis 80 mg tablets

  11. Pingback: Cialis 60 mg otc

  12. Pingback: sildenafil 130 mg canada

  13. Pingback: cheap levitra 40 mg

  14. Pingback: propecia 1 mg usa

  15. Pingback: lexapro 5 mg for sale

  16. Pingback: aldactone 100mg medication

  17. Pingback: buy cialis

  18. Pingback: cheapest arimidex 1 mg

  19. Pingback: ashwagandha 60caps otc

  20. Pingback: avapro 150 mg generic

  21. Pingback: bactrim 400/80 mg tablets

  22. Pingback: benicar 10 mg otc

  23. Pingback: Premarin 0,625mg no prescription

  24. Pingback: calcium carbonate 500 mg online pharmacy

  25. Pingback: cardizem 60 mg cheap

  26. Pingback: order catapres 100mcg

  27. Pingback: how to purchase ceftin

  28. Pingback: celebrex 100mg nz

  29. Pingback: celexa tablet

  30. Pingback: cephalexin cost

  31. Pingback: cipro prices

  32. Pingback: claritin 10 mg without a doctor prescription

  33. Pingback: real money online casinos usa

  34. Pingback: doubleu casino

  35. Pingback: gambling games

  36. Pingback: online casino games real money

  37. Pingback: golden nugget online casino

  38. Pingback: casino online real money

  39. Pingback: best online casino real money

  40. Pingback: online casino gambling

  41. Pingback: online casino

  42. Pingback: auto and home insurance quotes

  43. Pingback: autoowners insurance

  44. Pingback: collector car insurance quotes

  45. Pingback: california car insurance quotes

  46. Pingback: insurance for cars

  47. Pingback: nationwide insurance

  48. Pingback: best car insurance

  49. Pingback: online personal loans

  50. Pingback: payday loans raleigh nc

  51. Pingback: installment loans online

  52. Pingback: quick loans online

  53. Pingback: bad credit loans

  54. Pingback: fast payday loans

  55. Pingback: advance personal loans online

  56. Pingback: high cbd cannabis seeds for sale

  57. Pingback: strongest cbd oil for sale

  58. Pingback: best cbd oil for pain and inflammation

  59. Pingback: health benefits of cbd hemp oil

  60. Pingback: cbd oil for sale in colorado springs

  61. Pingback: cbd oil online amazon

  62. Pingback: reviews of cbd gummies for teens

  63. Pingback: step to write an essay

  64. Pingback: my essay writing

  65. Pingback: professional research paper writers

  66. Pingback: buy a essay

  67. Pingback: write an argument essay

  68. Pingback: buy nothing day essay

  69. Pingback: college paper writers

  70. Pingback: how to become a better essay writer

  71. Pingback: writers workshop paper

  72. Pingback: where to buy cleocin

  73. Pingback: clomid online pharmacy

  74. Pingback: how to purchase clonidine 0,1 mg

  75. Pingback: buy combivent 50/20mcg

  76. Pingback: compazine 5 mg without prescription

  77. Pingback: cheap crestor 5 mg

  78. Pingback: dapsone caps coupon

  79. Pingback: depakote uk

  80. Pingback: how to buy differin 15g

  81. Pingback: diltiazem 60 mg cost

  82. Pingback: cost of doxycycline

  83. Pingback: dramamine 50 mg otc

  84. Pingback: where can i buy elavil

  85. Pingback: erythromycin 250mg usa

  86. Pingback: etodolac 400 mg canada

  87. Pingback: flomax 0,2 mg otc

  88. Pingback: hyzaar tablet

  89. Pingback: order imdur

  90. Pingback: imodium 2 mg united kingdom

  91. Pingback: visit

  92. Pingback: imuran generic

  93. Pingback: lopid 300mg without prescription

  94. Pingback: lopressor 100mg canada

  95. Pingback: luvox 100 mg cheap

  96. Pingback: meclizine united kingdom

  97. Pingback: mestinon over the counter

  98. Pingback: micardis 40mg united states

  99. Pingback: mobic generic

  100. Pingback: motrin 200 mg pharmacy

  101. Pingback: order periactin 4mg

  102. Pingback: plaquenil 200mg medication

  103. Pingback: prevacid 15mg generic

  104. Pingback: prilosec 10mg united states

  105. Pingback: order procardia

  106. Pingback: proscar 5mg for sale

  107. Pingback: protonix online

  108. Pingback: provigil canada

  109. Pingback: how to buy pulmicort

  110. Pingback: pyridium nz

  111. Pingback: reglan 10 mg pills

  112. Pingback: remeron without a prescription

  113. Pingback: revatio australia

  114. Pingback: risperdal coupon

  115. Pingback: robaxin 500mg no prescription

  116. Pingback: singulair tablets

  117. Pingback: skelaxin 400mg purchase

  118. Pingback: where can i buy spiriva 9mcg

  119. Pingback: how to buy tenormin

  120. Pingback: thorazine 50 mg united states

  121. Pingback: toprol 50mg nz

  122. Pingback: tricor 200mg pharmacy

  123. Pingback: valtrex australia

  124. Pingback: how to buy vantin 100 mg

  125. Pingback: verapamil without a prescription

  126. Pingback: voltaren 100 mg price

  127. Pingback: wellbutrin 300 mg generic

  128. Pingback: check over here

  129. Pingback: zocor for sale

  130. Pingback: zovirax 400 mg over the counter

  131. Pingback: cheapest zyloprim 300 mg

  132. Pingback: zyprexa 10mg prices

  133. Pingback: zyvox without prescription

  134. Pingback: sildenafil without a prescription

  135. Pingback: where to buy tadalafil

  136. Pingback: cheap pioglitazone 15 mg

  137. Pingback: spironolactone prices

  138. Pingback: fexofenadine without a doctor prescription

  139. Pingback: leflunomide 20 mg without a doctor prescription

  140. Pingback: cost of anastrozole

  141. Pingback: irbesartan united states

  142. Pingback: dutasteride 0,5mg price

  143. Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg united states

  144. Pingback: cefuroxime 125 mg cost

  145. Pingback: celecoxib pharmacy

  146. Pingback: citalopram 20mg nz

  147. Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg coupon

  148. Pingback: ciprofloxacin online pharmacy

  149. Pingback: how to buy clindamycin 150mg

  150. Pingback: clozapine online

  151. Pingback: prochlorperazine 5mg cost

  152. Pingback: warfarin 2 mg without prescription

  153. Pingback: rosuvastatin united states

  154. Pingback: divalproex 500 mg uk

  155. Pingback: cheap tolterodine 1mg

  156. Pingback: cheap fluconazole 150mg

  157. Pingback: oxybutynin cost

  158. Pingback: cost of doxycycline 100mg

  159. Pingback: bisacodyl 5mg coupon

  160. Pingback: venlafaxine 37.5 mg cost

  161. Pingback: cheapest amitriptyline

  162. Pingback: permethrin 30g no prescription

  163. Pingback: erythromycin cost

  164. Pingback: estradiol over the counter

  165. Pingback: buy alendronate 70mg

  166. Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100 mg without a prescription

  167. Pingback: glipizide prices

  168. Pingback: order isosorbide 60mg

  169. Pingback: loperamide 2 mg without prescription

  170. Pingback: azathioprine 25mg uk

  171. Pingback: cheapest propranolol 40 mg

  172. Pingback: how to purchase indomethacin 75 mg

  173. Pingback: lamotrigine 50mg without prescription

  174. Pingback: cost of terbinafine 250mg

  175. Pingback: levofloxacin 750mg pharmacy

  176. Pingback: levothyroxine mcg coupon

  177. Pingback: atorvastatin australia

  178. Pingback: where to buy gemfibrozil 300mg

  179. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine plaquenil side effects

Leave a Reply