Spoilers below for those who haven’t finished the book.
Having read the final parts of the book, I feel heartbroken at the deaths of the baby and Catherine. Hemingway set up the final chapters of the book in a way that made us anxious as we knew something awful was about to happen. There was much foreshadowing with the weather, the constant, dreadful descriptions of the rain and snow. It was bitter and concerning, especially considering the way Catherine had previously described how she hated the rain because she ”pictured Henry dead in it”. Hemingway is setting us up for the ending – we knew something vicous would happen, maybe Henry caught and arrested, but personally I was not expecting the death of both Catherine and the baby.
The way Hemingway also accelerates the months and portrays the time passing makes us apprehensive as we are made to feel as if something is coming – but we didn’t know what (besides the baby of course). Chapter 40 – ‘We lived through the months of January and February and the winter was very fine and we were very happy…In March came the first break in the winter. In the night it had started raining. ” Hemingway displays the months passing rapidly and thus the arrival of a sinister event is also following it, and there is almost a sense of irony in ‘we were very happy’ as we know the raw realism Hemingway is known for will eventually catch up, as much I was hoping it wouldn’t. The foreboding ‘rain’ just accentuates the harrowing events that we will eventually see, and it’s also very fitting how Henry is described as ‘walking out in the rain’ in the very last sentence of the novel: he has survived this far but at what cost?
Amidst all the chaos and destruction of the war, which Hemingway is able to point towards subtly by the fact that Henry still occasionally reads the papers, I was hoping that happiness would be able to outlive it, and that something as happy as Catherine’s and Henry’s relationship would last. As crazy as their relationship was, as well as their pretend marriage and their made up family existence (Catherine tells her hairdresser she has two boys and two girls), they were still content with each other and at times it was entertaining even to see them interact with the dialogue Hemingway includes. I think he led me to like their relationship, which is why I’m hurt at their demise.
I really liked how you explained and incorporated the weather as symbolic and foreshadowing. I never really thought about it like that but it completely makes sense! I thought that Henry and Cat’s relationship through the novel was forced at times and overall weird, but they seemed to fit each other in a very broken and odd way. They understood each other’s emptiness, brokenness, and sadness. I wished that they had had their daughter, I feel like Henry would have loved the baby if it had been a little Cat like they had talked about. I wish the baby had survived, some of the alternate endings allow me to believe that the baby could be alive if I believe it hard enough, but I don’t think Henry would love the boy much. I wish Catherine had survived, I wish they could have gotten real married as they planned. I feel bad for Henry, for the heartbreak he gets put through and the guilt he must feel for it all since he got Catherine pregnant and that is ultimately what killed her. The ending crushed me, though I knew there was no way this book could end neatly with a little bow wrapped around it. There had to be devastation, and I had a gut feeling that by the end of this Henry would lose everything, including Cat.
I kind of expected the baby to die but when she went into labor it threw me off. The whole part with the doctor telling her to drink to “keep the baby small” made me think that he knew something they didn’t. It made me think that he was trying to make miscarrying less painful by somehow shrinking the baby with the amount of alcohol she consumed (I don’t know how pregnancy and alcohol work). We all know you aren’t supposed to drink alcohol while you’re pregnant because it somehow negatively impacts the baby; so the doctor advising her to have wine was a big red flag to me. When she went into labor I thought everything would be fine and maybe the baby would live. I don’t understand why the doctor and nurses would let her go through such a long labor if they may have known beforehand that the baby wasn’t going to make it (drinking to keep it small). Although now that I am thinking about it and typing this maybe they figured out somehow that they weren’t actually married and wanted them to “pay” for their sins. I mean people in this time are very religious, especially the older generation. Still I was shocked and upset when the baby was born dead and the last thing I expected was for Cat to die. When Henry started panicking I kind of figured it out but thats also way to late to say you figured it out. I have a lot of emotions about the end of this book… like what did Hemingway just put us through and why? He must be a sociopath.
Pingback: cialis 20mg
Pingback: canadian generic viagra
Pingback: buy ciprofloxacin
Pingback: albuterol without dr prescription usa
Pingback: naltrexone price in india
Pingback: buy tylenol online
Pingback: buy chloroquine
Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine
Pingback: no doctor viagra without a doctor prescription
Pingback: generic viagra us
Pingback: buy careprost online in canada
Pingback: cialis without doctor prescription
Pingback: order viagra online
Pingback: canadian generic viagra online
Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online
Pingback: buy cialis
Pingback: cheapest Cialis 20 mg
Pingback: Cialis 40mg canada
Pingback: Cialis 80mg united kingdom
Pingback: sildenafil 120mg price
Pingback: buy tadalafil 10mg
Pingback: cheap furosemide 40mg
Pingback: actos 30mg online pharmacy
Pingback: allegra 180mg united states
Pingback: strattera 40 mg uk
Pingback: aricept 10mg uk
Pingback: order tamoxifen 10mg
Pingback: atarax 25mg united states
Pingback: augmentin 750/250 mg without a prescription
Pingback: avapro 300 mg over the counter
Pingback: avodart 0,5 mg generic
Pingback: cardizem 90 mg australia
Pingback: ceftin tablets
Pingback: cost of celebrex 100 mg
Pingback: celexa prices
Pingback: cipro 750mg medication
Pingback: claritin tablet
Pingback: real casino games
Pingback: casino slot
Pingback: casino online gambling
Pingback: online casino with free signup bonus real money usa
Pingback: real money online casinos usa
Pingback: real online casino
Pingback: freeway car insurance
Pingback: allstate insurance car
Pingback: first acceptance insurance
Pingback: full coverage insurance
Pingback: geico car insurance
Pingback: home and car insurance quotes
Pingback: best home and car insurance quotes companies
Pingback: personal loans online
Pingback: check into cash
Pingback: payday loans
Pingback: online quick loans texas
Pingback: easy bad credit loans
Pingback: best cbd oil for cancer for sale
Pingback: cbd hemp oil benefits amazon
Pingback: cbd oil from colorado for cancer patients
Pingback: how to use cbd oil
Pingback: cbd hemp oil for sale
Pingback: cbd oil for pain relief where to buy
Pingback: write a persuasive essay
Pingback: buy pre written essays
Pingback: buying essays online safe
Pingback: custom essay writers
Pingback: cleocin without a prescription
Pingback: clozaril 50mg uk
Pingback: coumadin 1 mg tablet
Pingback: crestor canada
Pingback: cheapest cymbalta 40mg
Pingback: dapsone caps without a doctor prescription
Pingback: depakote tablet
Pingback: diamox 250mg otc
Pingback: differin 15g united states
Pingback: cheapest dramamine 50 mg
Pingback: how to buy erythromycin
Pingback: etodolac 400 mg united states
Pingback: order flomax
Pingback: flonase nasal spray nz
Pingback: buy geodon
Pingback: hyzaar online
Pingback: imitrex 50 mg price
Pingback: levaquin price
Pingback: cheap lopid
Pingback: macrobid generic
Pingback: motrin 600 mg for sale
Pingback: cheap periactin 4 mg
Pingback: cheapest plaquenil
Pingback: prevacid otc
Pingback: prilosec 40 mg uk
Pingback: order proair inhaler 100mcg
Pingback: proscar 5mg for sale
Pingback: protonix 20mg without prescription
Pingback: provigil 100 mg pharmacy
Pingback: where to buy remeron 30 mg
Pingback: retin-a cream pills
Pingback: risperdal 3mg uk
Pingback: rogaine cheap
Pingback: where to buy skelaxin 400 mg
Pingback: spiriva coupon
Pingback: tenormin 50 mg tablet
Pingback: toprol canada
Pingback: tricor 200mg united kingdom
Pingback: verapamil without prescription
Pingback: voltaren 50 mg prices
Pingback: wellbutrin 300mg otc
Pingback: zanaflex for sale
Pingback: how to buy zithromax
Pingback: zyprexa 10 mg without a prescription
Pingback: zyvox usa
Pingback: cost of furosemide
Pingback: aripiprazole generic
Pingback: spironolactone 25 mg usa
Pingback: where to buy glimepiride
Pingback: cheapest meclizine 25 mg
Pingback: leflunomide over the counter
Pingback: cheap atomoxetine
Pingback: buspirone coupon
Pingback: order clonidinemg
Pingback: celecoxib otc
Pingback: citalopram 20 mg nz
Pingback: cephalexin 500mg uk
Pingback: ciprofloxacin pharmacy
Pingback: clindamycin 300mg united states
Pingback: clozapine 100mg uk
Pingback: rosuvastatin 20mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: acetazolamide united states
Pingback: oxybutynin uk
Pingback: doxycycline price
Pingback: bisacodyl usa
Pingback: amitriptyline united states
Pingback: how to purchase erythromycin
Pingback: estradiol 2 mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: how to buy tamsulosin
Pingback: fluticasone 50 mcg online
Pingback: alendronate nz
Pingback: nitrofurantoin otc
Pingback: glipizide otc
Pingback: buy isosorbide 60 mg
Pingback: sumatriptan 50 mg united kingdom
Pingback: azathioprine no prescription
Pingback: indomethacin 50 mg tablets
Pingback: terbinafine generic
Pingback: digoxin for sale
Pingback: levofloxacin otc
Pingback: levothyroxine mcg tablets
Pingback: atorvastatin 40mg pills
Pingback: where can i buy gemfibrozil 300 mg
Pingback: clotrimazole coupon
Pingback: buy metoclopramide 10mg
Pingback: true authentic place to purchase generic cialis without prescription
Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription
Pingback: goat lice treatment ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectin for sale
Pingback: cialis coupon lilly
Pingback: canada cialis paypal
Pingback: sildenafil 50mg tablets
Pingback: ivermectin 6 mg for sale
Pingback: ivermectin tablets uk
Pingback: tadalafil generic canada
Pingback: azithromycin 600 mg