Is It Enough?

The death of both the body and soul in these stories intrigues me. The existential crisis idea comes into light literally with the story of the blind man. I argue that his blindness is metaphorical to the way people fear death. The knowledge he has, is how we are supposed to “see” suffering as a part of life rather than avoid it.

Therefore, I would argue that the postlapsarian character in the text is not the blind man but rather the nurse. She is blind to the recognition of pain, I think also making the nurse a female supports the post-Eden argument that Professor Scanlon was making.

In both texts we discussed how faith could be a scam that people buy into. Yet, I don’t think this is the point Borden tries to make. The faith we see in the texts does not make life easier. In fact I would argue it makes life a lot harder. The belief in an afterlife is not something that makes their life on earth necessarily better or that person better than anyone else. Our characters still suffer and die. Faith does not alleviate their pain, nor do they always accept death. Yet their faith seems to obey the presence of pain in this world. A believer can still say choose another person, or why me, or what is the purpose. But the essence of faith asks that believers not care about the reason for what sometimes feels like punishment, merely because such reasoning is incomprehensible. That is why the cup of coffee though small is the symbol of prosperity in a world of spiritual poverty, much like the widow giving two coins. Is it enough? I think the reason the nurse is happy in the beginning is because she feels purpose in even the small ways she helps others. She loses that when she begins to feel alone and not looked after like she has done for others. I think this is supposed to show two things. The first is the selfish nature of humanity and how we want our own pain to be stopped before others, much like the worse cases we decide who gets our attention and who doesn’t. Also, the breakdown of the nurse shows us what happens when we focus on being unable to stop death and therefore are unable to help another even in the littlest way. That is why the older ones appear at the end I believe. To show us the need to reach out even if it may do nothing whatsoever not because it makes you a better person or to help ourselves but because empathy is what keeps us human.

Faith is the cup of coffee in the sense that does not aim to take away the picture of how bleak everything is. Our characters still question why they are hurting, they still feel lost and hopeless sometimes like the blind man after all is said and done. However, with faith, with the coffee, with the crucifix before them, death is to be endured not diminished. Faith then is not being proposed as a feel-good and everything is better type of thing. It is a slow process demonstrated in the living of holiness through subtle acts of charity and humility in the midst of a world that is shrouded in violence and blackness, like the priest in Hemingway or Borden. I think this is what Borden is trying to get at in the image of the rabbi holding up the crucifix at the end, that someone was willing to help in a moment of distress as someone was there for you, regardless of what sect they belong to. That is an important lesson to learn whether you are a Christian, Jew, or Muslim.

In conclusion, today is All Saints Day in the Catholic Church. We have talked a little bit about how saints and angels have their role within religion and salvation. If faith was just some temporal comfort in Borden’s stories why does her characters die while reacting to it? Some would argue faith falls into the ideology of war, where you do your bit and are rewarded for it. That could be true, but just like the war itself, feeling or emotion is not the best motivator especially when you lose sight of what you believe you should be rewarded for in times of distress. Faith by obligation is what I say we experience in these stories. The witness that duty for another’s life comes before our own, that is our little cups of coffee or our crucifix holding. We all want to say I can help you, that I can take away the pain, yet this leads to the worst sense relativism from the absolute truth that certain aspects of faith depend on. You can not heal everyone, and often you can not heal yourself or stop death. It will come. There is death on this earth that much is known. So why pretend like we have a purpose in what we do if there is no God? I think this is the question Borden wants us to ask as we read about death and faith, and the hope that still somehow persists in the hopelessness.

273 thoughts on “Is It Enough?

  1. I honestly wasn’t really thinking about faith much when I was reading Borden, even when that was an explicit part of the story. Mostly, I was thinking about human connection. But I think your point about not having faith being harder, wondering why the war feels like a punishment, was intriguing to me. It definitely made me rethink some things.

  2. Pingback: cipro canada

  3. Pingback: ventolin canada

  4. Pingback: generic viagra sales

  5. Pingback: naltrzone online

  6. Pingback: tylenol 3 equivalent

  7. Pingback: chloroquine price

  8. Pingback: how do i buy viagra online

  9. Pingback: where to buy cialis

  10. Pingback: best viagra alternative

  11. Pingback: can viagra 100mg be dangerous

  12. Pingback: viagra 25mg

  13. Pingback: buy chloroquine phosphate

  14. Pingback:

  15. Pingback:

  16. Pingback: cialis vs viagra

  17. Pingback: cialis dose

  18. Pingback: viagra buy

  19. Pingback: viagra cost

  20. Pingback: Cialis 40 mg purchase

  21. Pingback: Cialis 80mg cost

  22. Pingback: Cialis 80mg nz

  23. Pingback: tadalafil 80mg uk

  24. Pingback: order levitra 60 mg

  25. Pingback: lasix 100mg uk

  26. Pingback: where to buy furosemide 100 mg

  27. Pingback: cost of propecia 5 mg

  28. Pingback: viagra dosage

  29. Pingback: viagra substitute

  30. Pingback: lexapro 20 mg generic

  31. Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription

  32. Pingback: aldactone 100mg medication

  33. Pingback: allegra 120mg cost

  34. Pingback: buy amaryl 2 mg

  35. Pingback: amoxicillin 250 mg canada

  36. Pingback: cheap ampicillin 500mg

  37. Pingback: antabuse 250 mg pharmacy

  38. Pingback: antivert 25 mg united kingdom

  39. Pingback: arava 10mg without a doctor prescription

  40. Pingback: buy strattera 40 mg

  41. Pingback: web store viagra

  42. Pingback: arimidex 1mg united kingdom

  43. Pingback: india generic cialis

  44. Pingback: augmentin 875/125 mg pills

  45. Pingback: cheap avapro 150 mg

  46. Pingback: viagra order in united states

  47. Pingback: avodart 0,5 mg uk

  48. Pingback: where can i buy baclofen 10 mg

  49. Pingback: bactrim 400/80mg cost

  50. Pingback: cialis kidney

  51. Pingback: benicar 20 mg without prescription

  52. Pingback: Biaxin 250mg nz

  53. Pingback: buy cialis uk

  54. Pingback: order buspar 5mg

  55. Pingback: shoppers drug mart viagra

  56. Pingback: ceclor 500 mg over the counter

  57. Pingback: ceftin 250 mg prices

  58. Pingback: celebrex 100mg price

  59. Pingback: celexa purchase

  60. Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg price

  61. Pingback: cipro 750mg generic

  62. Pingback: where can i buy claritin 10mg

  63. Pingback: hollywood casino online

  64. Pingback: real money casino app

  65. Pingback: slot machine

  66. Pingback: online slots for real money

  67. Pingback: casino games

  68. Pingback: casino gambling

  69. Pingback: online casino gambling

  70. Pingback: sugarhouse casino online

  71. Pingback: costco car insurance quotes

  72. Pingback: generic viagra from england

  73. Pingback: best car insurance quotes comparison site

  74. Pingback: rental car insurance quotes

  75. Pingback: car insurance quotes now

  76. Pingback: insurance quotes online comparison

  77. Pingback: car insurance quotes comparison online

  78. Pingback: vehicle insurance quotes

  79. Pingback: personal loans dallas tx

  80. Pingback: payday loans near me

  81. Pingback: 1 hour payday loans no credit check

  82. Pingback: installment loans mobile al

  83. Pingback: 1 hour bad credit loans no credit check

  84. Pingback: payday loans online

  85. Pingback: online personal loans no credit check

  86. Pingback: reviews of cbd gummies for teens

  87. Pingback: cbd oil

  88. Pingback: viagra sublingual absorption

  89. Pingback: cbd oil side effects stomach pain gas

  90. Pingback: does walmart sell cbd oil

  91. Pingback: hemp cbd oil benefits

  92. Pingback: cbd oil products

  93. Pingback: how does female viagra works

  94. Pingback: cbd oil amazon

  95. Pingback: buy essay online

  96. Pingback: viagra without seeing a doctor

  97. Pingback: assignment operators

  98. Pingback: best custom essay writing service

  99. Pingback: cheapest essay writing service uk

  100. Pingback: professional essay writer

  101. Pingback: dissertation online

  102. Pingback: college paper writer

  103. Pingback: online paper writer

  104. Pingback: how to purchase cleocin 300mg

  105. Pingback: cialis dosing

  106. Pingback: symbicort inhaler 160/4,5 mcg price

  107. Pingback: order combivent

  108. Pingback: coreg no prescription

  109. Pingback: coumadin cheap

  110. Pingback: tijuana pharmacy viagra

  111. Pingback: cost of cozaar

  112. Pingback: how to buy crestor 5mg

  113. Pingback: cymbalta 40 mg online

  114. Pingback: ddavp without a doctor prescription

  115. Pingback: depakote 250mg online pharmacy

  116. Pingback: diltiazem 30mg without a doctor prescription

  117. Pingback: doxycycline pharmacy

  118. Pingback: etodolac pills

  119. Pingback: flonase nasal spray united kingdom

  120. Pingback: cheapest garcinia cambogia 100caps

  121. Pingback: buy geodon 80mg

  122. Pingback: hyzaar 12,5 mg pharmacy

  123. Pingback: how to buy imdur

  124. Pingback: imitrex 25 mg purchase

  125. Pingback: imodium 2mg medication

  126. Pingback: you can check here

  127. Pingback: imuran united kingdom

  128. Pingback: cost of lamisil

  129. Pingback: cheapest levaquin

  130. Pingback: lopid usa

  131. Pingback: cheap lopressor

  132. Pingback: how to purchase macrobid 100mg

  133. Pingback: buy viagra fedex

  134. Pingback: mestinon usa

  135. Pingback: mobic united kingdom

  136. Pingback: motrin 400mg tablet

  137. Pingback: us pharmacy online viagra

  138. Pingback: nortriptyline canada

  139. Pingback: periactin tablet

  140. Pingback: phenergan tablet

  141. Pingback: plaquenil without a doctor prescription

  142. Pingback: prevacid otc

  143. Pingback: prilosec 20mg medication

  144. Pingback: proair inhaler 100 mcg coupon

  145. Pingback: procardia price

  146. Pingback: protonix price

  147. Pingback: generic viagra pharmacy

  148. Pingback: provigil 100mg pharmacy

  149. Pingback: pyridium united states

  150. Pingback: where can i buy reglan 10 mg

  151. Pingback: retin-a cream tablets

  152. Pingback: revatio medication

  153. Pingback: risperdal for sale

  154. Pingback: rogaine 5% pharmacy

  155. Pingback: singulair australia

  156. Pingback: skelaxin without a prescription

  157. Pingback: cheap spiriva

  158. Pingback: order tenormin 100mg

  159. Pingback: thorazine 50mg without a prescription

  160. Pingback: tricor for sale

  161. Pingback: valtrex 500 mg prices

  162. Pingback: vantin usa

  163. Pingback: verapamil otc

  164. Pingback: voltaren 100mg canada

  165. Pingback: wellbutrin nz

  166. Pingback: brand cialis 100mg

  167. Pingback: zanaflex usa

  168. Pingback: zestril 10mg coupon

  169. Pingback: zithromax united kingdom

  170. Pingback: index

  171. Pingback: zocor online pharmacy

  172. Pingback: zovirax 200mg tablets

  173. Pingback: healthyman viagra

  174. Pingback: zyloprim 100 mg tablets

  175. Pingback: where to buy zyprexa

  176. Pingback: how to buy tadalafil

  177. Pingback: buy furosemide

  178. Pingback: escitalopram coupon

  179. Pingback: aripiprazole 20mg usa

  180. Pingback: pioglitazone 30 mg coupon

  181. Pingback: spironolactone 100mg cheap

  182. Pingback: glimepiride 1 mg australia

  183. Pingback: cheap leflunomide 20 mg

  184. Pingback: atomoxetine 10 mg pills

  185. Pingback: cheap donepezil

  186. Pingback: irbesartan 150mg generic

  187. Pingback: cheapest dutasteride

  188. Pingback: buspirone 10 mg uk

  189. Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg online

  190. Pingback: how to purchase citalopram

  191. Pingback: where to buy cephalexin 500 mg

  192. Pingback: how to purchase ciprofloxacin 750 mg

  193. Pingback: how to purchase loratadine 10mg

  194. Pingback: buy clindamycin

  195. Pingback: clozapine 25mg no prescription

  196. Pingback: prochlorperazine 5mg uk

  197. Pingback: carvedilol 25 mg for sale

  198. Pingback: warfarin 5 mg canada

  199. Pingback: rosuvastatin pills

  200. Pingback: divalproex without prescription

  201. Pingback: cost of trazodone

  202. Pingback: acetazolamide 250 mg online pharmacy

  203. Pingback: cheap phenytoin 100 mg

  204. Pingback: where to buy oxybutynin 5mg

  205. Pingback: doxycycline online

  206. Pingback: buy bisacodyl

  207. Pingback: venlafaxine 75 mg generic

  208. Pingback: amitriptyline price

  209. Pingback: permethrin 30g cost

  210. Pingback: erythromycin otc

  211. Pingback: xfociabx

  212. Pingback: estradiol uk

  213. Pingback: etodolac medication

  214. Pingback: fluticasone mcg coupon

  215. Pingback: alendronate medication

  216. Pingback: nitrofurantoin tablet

  217. Pingback: glipizide 5mg cheap

  218. Pingback: buy hydrochlorothiazide 10 mg

  219. Pingback: isosorbide without a prescription

  220. Pingback: sumatriptan without a prescription

  221. Pingback: order propranolol

  222. Pingback: indomethacin generic

  223. Pingback: lamotrigine cheap

  224. Pingback: terbinafine 250 mg without a doctor prescription

  225. Pingback: how to buy levothyroxine mcg

  226. Pingback: atorvastatin 40 mg online

  227. Pingback: gemfibrozil tablet

  228. Pingback: metoprolol without a prescription

  229. Pingback: clotrimazole uk

  230. Pingback: metoclopramide 10 mg without prescription

  231. Pingback: amoxicillin 825 mg

  232. Pingback: order lasix online

  233. Pingback: neurontin 500 mg

  234. Pingback: plaquenil 150 mg

  235. Pingback: 40 mcg prednisone

  236. Pingback: priligy medication

  237. Pingback: buy provigil onlinr

  238. Pingback: ivermectin lotion 0.5

  239. Pingback: cost of ventolin

  240. Pingback: buy zithromax online

  241. Pingback: 40 mg lasix

  242. Pingback: chloroquine 150 mg

  243. Pingback: provigil modafinil

  244. Pingback: ivermectin 4 mg

  245. Pingback: azithromycin 250mg

  246. Pingback: clomid 100

  247. Pingback: baricitinib cost

  248. Pingback: nolvadex buy uk

  249. Pingback: aralen 40 mg

  250. Pingback: lumigan 01

  251. Pingback: 12 mg zanaflex

  252. Pingback: 2leinster

  253. Pingback: madridbet

  254. Pingback: madridbet

  255. Pingback: madridbet

  256. Pingback: grandpashabet

  257. Pingback: Leandro Farland

  258. Pingback: Should I take probiotics every day with antibiotic hydroxychloroquine and psoriasis

  259. Pingback: How long does it take for good bacteria to grow back after antibiotics

  260. Pingback: What is attractive in a woman

  261. Pingback: How do you tell if it's really asthma

  262. Pingback: What vitamins increase serotonin

  263. Pingback: How often are ribs broken during CPR Zestril

  264. Pingback: Stromectol 3mg tablets

  265. Pingback: Cialis Tadalafil 20 mg: How long does it take a guy to realize he wants to marry you |

  266. Pingback: vidalista 20 reviews buy fildena 50mg online

  267. Pingback: What to avoid while on antibiotics Azithromycin antibiotics

  268. Pingback: Wie werde ich potenter kamagra shop 24

  269. Pingback: clomiphene citrate 50mg tablets

  270. Pingback: Quels sont les differents problemes de la famille pharmacie en ligne hollande

  271. Pingback: Quelles sont les causes de la famille comment se procurer des medicaments sans

  272. Pingback: buy letrozole without prescription

  273. Pingback: How do you exercise in bed?

Leave a Reply