I want to open a spot for discussion here.
In chapter nine, Paul achieves his first personal kill in the war by mortally wounding a French soldier. Instead of leaving him to die, however, Paul is overcome with immense guilt and tries to make the man’s passing comfortable- or about as comfortable you can be on the battlefield.
The point of interest is the little speech he gives after the soldier dies. He claims to have finally seen that this man wasn’t just an enemy soldier, but a person with a family and a life just like him.
“Why do they never tell us that you poor devils are like us… that we have the same fear of death… how could you be my enemy?”
We have talked about desensitization and the “spell” of it being broken in class. Only instead of it happening at home, it’s happened to Paul on the battlefield. Despite everything Paul has been through at this point, has the war been made more real for him? Paul no longer considers himself a child- the war has changed him- but had he still held a certain ignorance that killing soldier killed as well? Does the fact he decides not to keep the promises he made the dead soldier subvert any sort of realization he may have had?
What I find most interesting here is when Paul is broken out of the “spell” as we have called it. He came to this moment of realizing that all the men out here fighting all have someone back home they are trying to get back to, they were someone’s son, brother, husband, and maybe even father. This snap back into ‘reality’ I guess you could say, or moment of understanding shows how Paul kind of questions the war and its intent now. To me, even for a minute, it showed the more human side of Paul and not the mechanical or animalistic one we have talked about in class.
I definitely agree with you that this scene showed the “spell” of war, or perhaps it would be more accurate to claim that it was the “spell” of the propaganda, that was broken for Paul. To me, I feel that through his internal dialogue we have access to the way he feels he needs to think (and has overtime learned to think in such way), and then we also have access to his real thoughts. Paul, who I feel can be seen to represent his generation as a whole, has been thrust into a situation that no one should ever experience. At a crucial time in his life, instead of being given the freedom to develop his own identity, he was thrust into the trenches. His options were to either mentally and physically toughen up, or have a higher chance of dying or losing his mind. He did what was told of him and I feel that from the time he goes and comes back from leave, to the end of the novel, reality hits him harsher than any propaganda can. With that in mind, back on the front, he has to ignore what he has come to learn about reality and shift back into a soldier mentality. It is not until he is isolated, with only the dying soldier he attacked as company, that he is allowed to act on and allow himself to analyze the reality of the situation. In this scene, just as others have already pointed out, he is finally allowed to be (and feel) human.
I totally agree with you Meaghan. It’s almost as if in this scene Paul is given the go-ahead to de-mechanize himself–to become human again.
Pingback: ventolin no prescription
Pingback: lowest price on generic cialis 40mg
Pingback: buy naltrexone online usa
Pingback: chloroquine otc
Pingback: buy cialis
Pingback: careprost better to buy
Pingback: how long does cialis last
Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online
Pingback: mymvrc.org
Pingback: order Cialis 40mg
Pingback: how to buy sildenafil 25 mg
Pingback: cheap lasix 40 mg
Pingback: where to buy lexapro 5mg
Pingback: cialistodo.com
Pingback: bactrim 800/160 mg for sale
Pingback: cost of catapres 100mcg
Pingback: how to purchase ceftin
Pingback: cost of celebrex
Pingback: celexa 10 mg united states
Pingback: cheapest claritin
Pingback: best slots to play online
Pingback: play casino online
Pingback: gambling games
Pingback: rivers casino
Pingback: casino slot
Pingback: empire casino online
Pingback: real money online casino
Pingback: jackpot party casino
Pingback: car insurance usaa
Pingback: online car insurance quotes
Pingback: cure car insurance
Pingback: car insurance quotes in michigan
Pingback: car insurance quotes for young drivers
Pingback: rbc car insurance
Pingback: car insurance online now
Pingback: instant payday loans online
Pingback: installment loans online loans
Pingback: illinois quick loans
Pingback: bad credit loans bad credit loans
Pingback: payday loans san bernardino
Pingback: difference between cbd oil and hemp oil
Pingback: cbd oil side effects
Pingback: cbd oil for anxiety
Pingback: cbd oil for pain for sale
Pingback: cbd oil for anxiety
Pingback: mymathlab answers to homework
Pingback: school assignments
Pingback: how to write an intro for an essay
Pingback: custom essay writer
Pingback: essay writer reviews
Pingback: write my essays for me
Pingback: essay writing services reviews
Pingback: top 10 essay writing services
Pingback: cleocin 300mg tablets
Pingback: clomid united states
Pingback: clonidine 0,1 mg nz
Pingback: clozaril united kingdom
Pingback: buy colchicine 0,5 mg
Pingback: combivent 50/20mcg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: compazine purchase
Pingback: coumadin online
Pingback: crestor 5mg cost
Pingback: cymbalta 30 mg medication
Pingback: dapsone caps no prescription
Pingback: depakote 250mg price
Pingback: differin without a prescription
Pingback: where to buy diltiazem 90 mg
Pingback: doxycycline 100 mg usa
Pingback: dramamine 50mg tablet
Pingback: elavil for sale
Pingback: flomax online pharmacy
Pingback: flonase nasal spray 50 mcg no prescription
Pingback: garcinia cambogia caps generic
Pingback: hyzaar 12,5mg purchase
Pingback: imdur tablet
Pingback: where to buy imitrex 50mg
Pingback: imodium 2 mg medication
Pingback: use this link
Pingback: imuran cheap
Pingback: indocin 75mg tablets
Pingback: lamisil australia
Pingback: levaquin 500 mg cheap
Pingback: lopid no prescription
Pingback: cheap macrobid
Pingback: meclizine 25mg otc
Pingback: how to buy mestinon 60 mg
Pingback: micardis australia
Pingback: mobic 15mg over the counter
Pingback: order motrin 600mg
Pingback: periactin 4mg without a prescription
Pingback: prevacid 30 mg usa
Pingback: cheapest prilosec
Pingback: cost of procardia 30mg
Pingback: how to purchase proscar 5mg
Pingback: protonix 20mg for sale
Pingback: provigil uk
Pingback: pulmicort 100mcg no prescription
Pingback: pyridium 200mg cost
Pingback: reglan 10 mg generic
Pingback: remeron australia
Pingback: retin-a cream without a prescription
Pingback: revatio without a prescription
Pingback: risperdal 1 mg uk
Pingback: cheapest robaxin
Pingback: order rogaine 5%
Pingback: where can i buy singulair 10 mg
Pingback: skelaxin 400mg online pharmacy
Pingback: how to purchase tenormin 100mg
Pingback: cost of thorazine
Pingback: toprol canada
Pingback: tricor 200 mg australia
Pingback: verapamil generic
Pingback: wellbutrin 150 mg otc
Pingback: how to purchase zanaflex 4mg
Pingback: More hints
Pingback: how to purchase zovirax
Pingback: zyloprim usa
Pingback: zyvox 600 mg purchase
Pingback: sildenafil united kingdom
Pingback: cheapest furosemide 100 mg
Pingback: aripiprazole 15 mg without a prescription
Pingback: pioglitazone online
Pingback: spironolactone purchase
Pingback: fexofenadine 180mg uk
Pingback: glimepiride medication
Pingback: how to buy meclizine
Pingback: leflunomide 20mg uk
Pingback: atomoxetine canada
Pingback: order anastrozole 1mg
Pingback: where to buy olmesartan 10mg
Pingback: buspirone 10mg tablet
Pingback: cefuroxime nz
Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg pharmacy
Pingback: ciprofloxacin coupon
Pingback: clozapine pills
Pingback: cost of warfarin
Pingback: where can i buy rosuvastatin 10 mg
Pingback: cheapest desmopressin 10 mcg
Pingback: divalproex 250mg online pharmacy
Pingback: acetazolamide without prescription
Pingback: phenytoin 100 mg uk
Pingback: doxycycline 100mg cheap
Pingback: bisacodyl 5 mg tablets
Pingback: venlafaxine uk
Pingback: permethrin pharmacy
Pingback: how to purchase erythromycin
Pingback: estradiol over the counter
Pingback: etodolac 400mg united states
Pingback: how to buy fluticasone 50 mcg
Pingback: alendronate without a doctor prescription
Pingback: order nitrofurantoin
Pingback: how to purchase glipizide
Pingback: sumatriptan 50 mg over the counter
Pingback: loperamide generic
Pingback: azathioprine medication
Pingback: how to buy propranolol 40 mg
Pingback: buy indomethacin
Pingback: lamotrigine 200mg nz
Pingback: terbinafine prices
Pingback: levothyroxine mcg usa
Pingback: gemfibrozil pharmacy
Pingback: clotrimazole without a doctor prescription
Pingback: how to buy metoclopramide 10mg