(Formal post title: Alex R’s review of Forbidden Ground)
For all the literature and art spurned by the First World War, no matter how belated, Forbidden Ground (the movie from 2013), must be some of the worst. All this movie amounts to is essentially a cliché of a poorly written plot, which was then subjected to messy camerawork, CGI, and awkward editing to make the whole thing even more convoluted. The movie even showcased blatant inaccuracies about the war, which made me question the research which went into its production.
For starters we should talk about the plot. Forbidden Ground centers around a small cadre of English soldiers who survive their compatriots after they are sent on an obviously vindictive and ill-planned mission to charge across no-man’s land and attack the German trenches. Somehow, the movie inspired no sympathy for the characters – in fact I’m sitting here ten minutes after watching it for a second time and I can’t remember their individual names (the only character’s name who I can think of is the protagonist’s wife, Grace.) The French commanding officer is a caricature of gay-coded “bad guy” tropes, and the German commanding officer is clearly just supposed to be evil because he looks evil as a result of a massive scar on his face; neither of these characters are convincing in any way, and neither makes me sympathize with the protagonist. On top of that, the only reason we are given to like the main character is that he has a wife at home who he misses, and the only way we know this is because he writes to her twice in the movie and carries a picture of her in his notebook. While this maybe would have worked better in a different context, it’s overdramatized here – it feels forced in its execution. Similarly, neither he nor his companions change at all over the course of the movie, they are all flat characters from beginning to end. The only person I feel anything for in the whole movie is Grace, the wife, s̵h̵e̵’̵s̵ ̵m̵a̵r̵r̵i̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵o̵ ̵s̵u̵c̵h̵ ̵a̵ ̵b̵o̵r̵i̵n̵g̵ ̵g̵u̵y̵(pretend that’s formatted with a real strikethrough) because she’s trying to get an abortion and is turned away. This is much more compelling than the primary plot of the movie, although it’s also overdramatized – the dialogue is all forced and hackneyed together. On top of all this, the resolution is unrealistic: there’s supposed to be a parallelism or an inversion of tropes in that she dies and he doesn’t, but it feels emotionless, partially because of the lack of reaction on the husband’s part: he just walks up to her grave in a little voiceover, drops a letter there, and strolls away. Not very emotional or consistant; if she was truly his reason to survive the war, I’d expect a different response.
On top of the poor writing, the production itself was really not great. There were clearly lots of CGI people, weapons, and blood splatters which really took me out of the story – it was hard not to laugh at some points. Also, whenever the characters were in a trench it was hard to tell where exactly they were; there was a weird lack of geographical understanding which made the whole movie hard to follow. This also goes for the no-man’s land; it was hard to tell the distance between the two lines of trenches because there was never any aerial shot (or anything at all) which helped to decode the landscape. Then there are the voiceovers, another element which made it hard to take Forbidden Land seriously. At a lot of points, it’s clear that the actors either didn’t say their lines correctly, or that they changed the lines in post production, so they just dubbed over the original sound with the new script, making it hard to tell who’s talking and taking the words out of sync with the actors’ mouths. All of these issues just really took me out of the content the film was trying to convey.
Perhaps worst of all though are the glaring historical inconsistencies. While there were smaller ones, like the young soldier having an bleach blond-to-ombre undercut, the big one was that the attitude on the homefront seemed totally different that what I’ve understood it to be. At one point the young soldier was talking about how he promised to his mate’s mother that he’d look after him; this promise seems wrong in that his mother would likely have been proud, or even egging her son to go to war. Grace’s attitude also felt inaccurate (along with that of her nurse), her husband was at war and I would have expected her to be more prideful as opposed to mourning. Although maybe these issues have to do more with the fact that I have no idea at what point during the war this movie takes place, not once during the movie do they give you the year – not even during the atrocious epistolary voice over sections.
In sum: Forbidden Land was a mess. It was poorly written, produced, and researched. Maybe these has to do with the fact that it was written, directed, and starred in one guy? Johan Earl, if you’re reading this, please do a better job next time; your extras were better actors than you. This movie was a poor representation of World War 1 and just bad movie as a whole.
(wc: 893)
That’s unfortunate that the characters are not dynamic and loosely based on their appearance. Also, as we’ve learned from the class, the topography of the land–the layout of the trenches–is so crucial to understanding the war, so its sad that that was underdeveloped
Pingback: where to buy ciprofloxacin
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine prophylaxis
Pingback: discount viagra usa
Pingback: buy chloroquine phosphate
Pingback: get viagra fast
Pingback: Cialis 60 mg purchase
Pingback: Cialis 20mg coupon
Pingback: lasix 100 mg canada
Pingback: furosemide 100mg canada
Pingback: how to buy propecia 1mg
Pingback: how to purchase lexapro 20 mg
Pingback: abilify 10 mg uk
Pingback: allegra 180 mg online
Pingback: amaryl 1 mg for sale
Pingback: how to purchase amoxicillin 250mg
Pingback: antabuse 500 mg canada
Pingback: how to buy antivert 25mg
Pingback: cost of arava 10mg
Pingback: aricept 5mg otc
Pingback: tamoxifen 10 mg medication
Pingback: atarax 10mg pharmacy
Pingback: order augmentin 500/125mg
Pingback: avapro 300mg pills
Pingback: baclofen 25 mg usa
Pingback: benicar 40 mg tablet
Pingback: Biaxin 250mg canada
Pingback: Premarin 0,3mg purchase
Pingback: ceclor without a prescription
Pingback: ceftin 125mg over the counter
Pingback: celebrex 200mg coupon
Pingback: celexa online
Pingback: how to purchase cephalexin 500mg
Pingback: claritin canada
Pingback: play casino
Pingback: san manuel casino online
Pingback: parx casino online
Pingback: casino slots gambling
Pingback: wind creek casino online play
Pingback: casino online real money
Pingback: casinos online
Pingback: safe car insurance
Pingback: collector car insurance quotes
Pingback: ameriprise car insurance quotes costco
Pingback: direct car insurance
Pingback: cheap full coverage car insurance quotes
Pingback: owners car insurance
Pingback: cheap car insurance quotes online
Pingback: personal loans in memphis tn
Pingback: guaranteed payday loans
Pingback: payday loans for bad credit
Pingback: instant online installment loan
Pingback: quick loans mn
Pingback: bad credit loans bad credit loans
Pingback: payday loans nj
Pingback: cbd oil sale
Pingback: bill gates cbd oil
Pingback: cbd oil for dogs with anxiety
Pingback: cbd oil for cancer sale
Pingback: what is cbd oil used for
Pingback: cbd oil for sale in bulk
Pingback: best cbd hemp oil for pain
Pingback: can you vape cbd oil
Pingback: benefits of cbd oil
Pingback: buying an essay
Pingback: top rated essay writing service
Pingback: legitimate essay writing service
Pingback: how to write a community service essay
Pingback: how to write an essays
Pingback: buying essays online
Pingback: best uk essay writing service
Pingback: online essay writing services
Pingback: buying essays online safe
Pingback: cleocin prices
Pingback: buy clomid
Pingback: clonidine online pharmacy
Pingback: colchicine tablet
Pingback: combivent 50/20mcg generic
Pingback: coreg price
Pingback: cheapest compazine 5mg
Pingback: coumadin online pharmacy
Pingback: cozaar 100mg medication
Pingback: where to buy crestor
Pingback: cymbalta 30mg pharmacy
Pingback: ddavp 0.1 mg medication
Pingback: depakote 500mg medication
Pingback: diamox without a prescription
Pingback: order differin 15g
Pingback: diltiazem without a prescription
Pingback: where can i buy doxycycline 100 mg
Pingback: dramamine coupon
Pingback: buy erythromycin 500 mg
Pingback: etodolac 200 mg price
Pingback: flomax online pharmacy
Pingback: how to buy flonase nasal spray
Pingback: garcinia cambogia 100caps online
Pingback: cheapest geodon 20mg
Pingback: hyzaar 12,5mg australia
Pingback: imdur generic
Pingback: where can i buy imitrex
Pingback: imodium uk
Pingback: her explanation
Pingback: imuran over the counter
Pingback: indocin 75mg coupon
Pingback: lamisil 250mg medication
Pingback: levaquin without a doctor prescription
Pingback: lopressor 100mg purchase
Pingback: luvox nz
Pingback: macrobid coupon
Pingback: mestinon coupon
Pingback: micardis 40 mg australia
Pingback: mobic 15mg tablet
Pingback: order motrin
Pingback: periactin 4 mg without a prescription
Pingback: plaquenil nz
Pingback: prevacid united states
Pingback: proair inhaler 100mcg online pharmacy
Pingback: procardia uk
Pingback: protonix 40mg coupon
Pingback: provigil 100 mg no prescription
Pingback: pulmicort 100mcg pharmacy
Pingback: reglan over the counter
Pingback: remeron cost
Pingback: revatio uk
Pingback: where to buy risperdal
Pingback: rogaine coupon
Pingback: seroquel online pharmacy
Pingback: singulair for sale
Pingback: where can i buy skelaxin
Pingback: spiriva online
Pingback: tenormin price
Pingback: thorazine otc
Pingback: toprol cost
Pingback: tricor uk
Pingback: cost of valtrex
Pingback: verapamil 120 mg purchase
Pingback: voltaren 100 mg pills
Pingback: zanaflex 4 mg for sale
Pingback: zestril 5 mg united states
Pingback: Discover More
Pingback: zocor 5 mg online
Pingback: zovirax 400mg united kingdom
Pingback: zyloprim 300 mg over the counter
Pingback: zyvox 600 mg tablets
Pingback: sildenafil usa
Pingback: furosemide 100 mg cheap
Pingback: aripiprazole 20mg coupon
Pingback: pioglitazone tablet
Pingback: spironolactone otc
Pingback: buy fexofenadine
Pingback: glimepiride 1 mg uk
Pingback: meclizine 25mg nz
Pingback: leflunomide tablets
Pingback: order donepezil
Pingback: cheapest anastrozole
Pingback: where can i buy irbesartan 150mg
Pingback: dutasteride purchase
Pingback: olmesartan united kingdom
Pingback: buspirone purchase
Pingback: how to buy clonidine 0.1 mg
Pingback: cefuroxime pharmacy
Pingback: citalopram 20 mg united kingdom
Pingback: cephalexin 500mg pills
Pingback: loratadine 10mg online pharmacy
Pingback: buy clindamycin 300mg
Pingback: where to buy clozapine 25mg
Pingback: how to buy prochlorperazine
Pingback: carvedilol 12.5mg online pharmacy
Pingback: warfarin medication
Pingback: desmopressin mcg canada
Pingback: tolterodine without a doctor prescription
Pingback: acetazolamide 250 mg otc
Pingback: fluconazole usa
Pingback: phenytoin tablet
Pingback: doxycycline 100mg over the counter
Pingback: bisacodyl 5 mg pharmacy
Pingback: venlafaxine canada
Pingback: amitriptyline 50 mg pharmacy
Pingback: permethrin 30g medication
Pingback: erythromycin without prescription
Pingback: cheapest estradiol
Pingback: where can i buy tamsulosin
Pingback: lpmzhvbv
Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100mg no prescription
Pingback: glipizide australia
Pingback: isosorbide 20 mg purchase
Pingback: cheapest azathioprine
Pingback: propranolol 80mg prices
Pingback: lamotrigine united states
Pingback: atorvastatin 40 mg no prescription
Pingback: metoprolol 50mg united states
Pingback: clotrimazole without a doctor prescription
Pingback: metformin 500mg tablets
Pingback: agoraphobic gay dating
Pingback: Arie Baisch
Pingback: Arie Baisch